Opening Credits[]
MALCOLM RAY
TAMARA CHAMBERS
ROB WALKER
HEATHER REUSZ
WALTER BANASIAK
JIM JAROSZ
AIYANNA WADE
A
DOUG WALKER
Film
Closing Credits[]
Directed & Edited by
DOUG WALKER
Written by
SCOTT SILVER
DOUG & ROB WALKER
Based on "Nostalgia Critic" by
DOUG WALKER
Produced by
CALE BOYTER, p.g.a
DON MURPHY
MARY PARENT, p.g.a.
DOUG WALKER
Executive Producers
BRIAN & KIM HERBERT
BYRON MERITT
ROB RENZETTI
Director of Photography
SALVATORE TOTINO, ASC, AC
Production Designer
AKIN McKENZIE
Costume Designers
JIM JAROSZ
BARNEY WALKER
Music by
MICHAEL SCHICIANO
Co-Producer
JONATHAN HINMAN
Supervising Sound Editor
ERIK AADAHL
Re-recording Mixer
RON BARTLETT
VFX Supervisor
FRAZER CHURCHILL
Casting by
KIM COLEMAN
A
CINEMASSACRE
INDIE RIGHTS
Distribution
A
CHANNEL AWESOME
Production
| Critic, Devil Boner, Chester, Uncle Lies, Schmuck clones, 1990 Pennywise, Stamp Zod, Raoul, Thade | Doug Walker |
| Mr. Breeder | Joaquin Phoenix |
| Rachel, Evilina, Rita Repulsa | Rachel Tietz |
| Dorian | Chad Doreck |
| The Top Secret Agent | Catherine Keener |
| Santa Christ, The Other Guy, Analyst, Impractical Joe | Rob Walker |
| Malcolm, Satan, Carrotjuice, Malcomous, Black Willy Wonka, Bill, Bennie, D-Bag, Menenist #1 | Malcolm Ray |
| Tamara, Aunt Despair, Hyper Fangirl, Tamity, Bum Jr., Awww Girl #1, D'awww Girl #1, Curiosa, Granny Tammy, Malice | Tamara Chambers |
| Critic's Dad | Barney Walker |
| Marthosa | Paulette Jones |
| Doe, Awww Girl #2, D'awww Girl #2 | Heather Reusz |
| Black Nerd | Andre Meadows |
| The Nerd, Voice of Super Mecha Death Bot | James Rolfe |
| Herself | Mara Wilson |
| Father Venkman, Arthur Fleck | Walter Banasiak |
| Himself | Dante Basco |
| Himself | Chris Stuckmann |
| Cinema Snob | Brad Jones |
| Himself | Jeremy Scott |
| Himself | Chris Atkinson |
| Himself, Voice of Soundwave | Jon Bailey |
| Himself | Tim Burton |
| Peter Soulless, Roger, the Angst | Orland Belisle Jr. |
| Jim, Harry Levin, Malachai, Menenist #2 | Jim Jarosz |
| Rob | Rob Scallon |
| Awww Girl #3, D'awww Girl #3 | Aiyanna Wade |
| Trevor, Shadow Leader | Trevor Mueller |
| Guitar Guy | Kyle Justin |
| 2010s' Pennywise | Bill Skarsgård |
| Landlord | David Cross |
| Lex Luthor | Jesse Eisenberg |
| Voice of Optimus Prime | Peter Cullen |
| Himself | Michael Bay |
| Himself | Zack Snyder |
| The Last Angry Geek, Menenist #3 | Brian Heinz |
| Superman | Henry Cavill |
| Batman | Christian Bale |
| DCEU Zod | Michael Shannon |
| Wonder Woman | Gal Gadot |
| Aquaman | Jason Momoa |
| Himself | Michael Salvatori |
| Linkara | Lewis Jeffrey Lovhaug |
| Cyborg | Ray Fisher |
| Shazam | Zachary Levi |
| Himself | Philo Barnhart |
| Lex Luthor | Jesse Eisenberg |