FANDOM


Idea Wiki Review is when admins or other users get to do their own review on other ideas and tell what is good or bad about those ideas.

Rules

  1. Use the table feature, 4 columns, and 2 rows
  2. Normal users are allowed to post their ideas for reviews.
  3. Any user can write a review.
  4. Any idea is allowed.
  5. If you write a bad review, curse words and bad language are not allowed.
  6. Using fictional characters (official or original) by admins and non-admins is not allowed.
  7. Users are allowed to write reviews on their own ideas.

Idea Reviews

SmashupMashups

Idea Review
Idea Clarence revival (Season 4 | Season 5 | Season 6 | Season 7)
Good Review
Bad Review CNReactionGuy18: It would be a good revial, but there are problems with it: First of all, Amy's return wasn't needed. I wanted her to still not appear, she's a good character. But it wasn't needed though. I didn't want her to get her character ruined. Secondly, the new character Andrew really sucked. If he was disliked. Why did he appear in this show then? As a gag? Thirdly, Sumo would've been in his former school by now since it's been destroyed by a wrecking ball. I do not kinda like the story with Clarence and Jeff moving there. And fourth: Some of the characters that I kinda liked disappeared.

Paula712: I prefer to not have a revival.

Idea Review
Idea Powerpuff Power Hour
Good Review Aldrine25: If this actually does get made, it would be a good way of reintroducing the 1998 Powerpuff Girls. Nice idea overall.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Nickelodeon Cinematic Animated Universe
Good Review Aldrine25: Great idea, since Nickelodeon should make more movies based on their cartoons.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Lord of the Rings: The Animated Series
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The CN Movie
Good Review Paula712: Cool!

Aldrine25: I think this is a good idea since Warner Bros. should make more movies based on Cartoon Network instead of only having The Powerpuff Girls Movie.

TobySilva77: If it was real, then i'll see at theaters with my friends. Great idea overall.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Clarence's Big Break
Good Review Aldrine25: If this movie gets created, Skyler Page would approve of it.
Bad Review

35Baragon

Idea Review
Idea Godzilla: New Age of Monsters
Good Review GreenGrassCreeper34: Since I'm a fan of Godzilla, it'd be willing to see a nice animated series based on one of the most popular movie monsters.

Iago PUC: Impressive idea, friend. Hope to see more about Godzilla soon.

35Baragon: Having superheroes and giant monsters together is great. 

TheLakesideMonster: A very neat and amazing take on Godzilla with an animated series. 

Coolot1: Eh, it's alright 

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Avengers High
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Racing 95
Good Review Mixelfan33: Racing 95 is a Awesome TV Show, I'm a big nascar fan and i will love to see a tv show of nascar, they got Paul Wesley being a serious driver, and Thomas Gibson being the bad guy, i like it.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea GodzillaVerse
Good Review Iago PUC: Quite a impressive number of movie and TV shows about the MonsterVerse. Truly.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Monster Kid
Good Review Iago PUC: So MonsterVerse has its own Ben 10... cool.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Young Justice (2019 TV series)
Good Review Iago PUC: Quite a interesting reboot or remake. Fascinating.

Paula712: This show become one interesting show that needed a reboot.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The New Scooby-Doo Movies (reboot)
Good Review 35Baragon: I love Scooby-Doo and the rest of Mystery Inc. The original New Scooby-Doo Movies was also great and the reboot has many characters from other shows and movies.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Godzilla: Monster Prime
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Marvel Alpha
Good Review
Bad Review

Cpend7

Idea Review
Idea Gregory Horror Show
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea PlayerUnknown's Battleground
Good Review
Bad Review

Sonic879

Idea Review
Idea The Brick (TV Series)
Good Review

35Baragon: Nice.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Trent: Martial Arts Extraordinaire
Good Review CLTwins15: I love it.

Paula712: It will be perfect!

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Kingdom Hearts: The Story Continues
Good Review
Bad Review

SpyroFanandCollinTSB

Idea Review
Idea Collin the Speedy Boy
Good Review

Coolot1: It's good.

DonaldoC1997: A creative way to fictionalize yourself with the influence of some well-known cartoons, video games and comic books.

Iago PUC: Not much of a fan of rip-offs, but this one is a creative one. Good job.

KKDisney: It's a wonderful superhero idea.

Firestrikerboss: Creative idea!

GreenGrassCreeper34: Pretty entertaining!

Paula712: Interesting idea!

Sonic879: It’s an awesome idea.

TobySilva77: Nice idea!

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Velocity: The Dark Human Slayer
Good Review Coolot1: This show is brilliant. Samurai Jack meets Jurassic Park meets I Am Legend.

KKDisney: It is one of the best darkest series, a great predecessor to Samurai Jack and a cool idea.

Bobbybooboobear: Now this show would be entertaining to watch if you're a fan of dinosaurs and fighting.

TheLakesideMonster: Could use a little paleontological accuracy, bu- just kidding. An epic mix that reminds me of Samurai Jack, but with a velociraptor instead.

GreenGrassCreeper34: Best cartoon idea I've ever seen from you!

Firestrikerboss: Great idea!

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Face Paint (species)
Good Review KKDisney: Great species.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Story of The Face Paint
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Foxtoons
Good Review KKDisney: A great cartoon series. Just as funny like Disney's Mickey Mouse, MGM cartoons and WB's Looney Tunes.

763492 is back: Neat concept. I wish if this was real. It’d be impressive if Disney buys out its cartoon rival like Foxtoons, it’d be like how WB already owns the MGM classic cartoon library and the old Popeye toons.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Tales of The Paintders
Good Review KKDisney: Good show. The only thing I don't get is why most of the villains are suprise vllains like most recent animated films.

GreenGrassCreeper34: Not bad. Not bad at all.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Face Paint'nimal Gang
Good Review GreenGrassCreeper34: Seems promising.
Bad Review

CLTwins15

Idea Review
Idea Ed, Edd n Eddy the Movie: The Ed-Touchables
Good Review

35Baragon: The episode with the same name is one of my episodes of Ed, Edd n Eddy. This movie is great since the show is one of Cartoon Network's most popular shows.

SpyroFanandCollinTSB: A really decent retelling of a beloved first episode of the beloved cartoon can show that a Cartoon Network reboot can be done properly.

Spider-GemBlur: I would love to watch this. This is how Cartoon Network should reboot their franchises, if done properly akin to Ultimate Marvel.

Coolot1: It's great. The casting is good and plot is good too.

Ricky2005: A good remake of a decent Cartoon Network show.

GreenGrassCreeper34: Nice! Ed, Edd 'n Eddy was one of my childhood shows.

Bad Review

GurPhin/Spider-GemBlur/Moon Silvight

Idea Review
Idea Miss Philippines (Franchise)
Good Review Coolot1: Actually not that bad.

Paula712: Good one.

Bad Review
Idea Princess Sally Acorn (Tekken 7 Guest)
Good Review
Bad Review  Wazzupguys: Eh, I don't know what to feel about this. But then again, both Noctis and Negan are also guests in Tekken 7.
Idea Max's Extremely Goofy College Life
Good Review
Bad Review

FERB-DROID

Idea Review
Idea March of the Robots (TV series)
Good Review Wazzupguys: keep up the good work.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Iron Giant: TV Series
Good Review

FERB-DROID: About series which should be issued in October 2001. Once this project looks proper. Dean McCoppin will be Hogarth's stepfather after the film. But there will be no new relative, and even Hogarth will not grow in the Ted Hughes' franchise. Nice project... Ricky2005: A great TV show adaptation of an extremely underrated movie.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Treasure Planet (George Stone's style)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Osmosis Jones
Good Review
Bad Review

GreenGrassCreeper34

Idea Review
Idea The Cryptids
Good Review

SpyroFanandCollinTSB: Perfect idea. Brilliant Cartoon Network show made by the same guys who did Catscratch.

DonaldoC1997: For the ones who loved Earthworm Jim and Catscratch, the sillyness of Doug TenNapel's cartoons is still there in a new and creative way.

Coolot1: A unique take on the Cryptids you fear.

KKDisney: Wonderful.

35Baragon: Great show! The second Cartoon Network show to have Cryptids.

Bobbybooboobear: A pretty wacky show kids would love to watch.

TheLakesideMonster: A true classic idea, ever since the days where you used to make these episodes on GoAnimate. Probably my favorite idea on this wiki!

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Eric and Claire
Good Review KKDisney: The series, despite having adult humor and a more mature revival, is a great cartoon.

Bobbybooboobear: A dark, but pretty cute show.

Firestrikerboss: Great buddy cartoon idea! Reminds me a lot of Billy and Mandy.

Paula712: I wish this become real.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Cartoon Network: CN School
Good Review SpyroFanandCollinTSB: This family-friendly comic, despite having some adult humor, is worth reading when you are bored or wanting a comic that is very humorous.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Molly Show
Good Review KKDisney: A great Maxwell Atoms show.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea ROBLOX: The Series
Good Review
Bad Review Paula712: Not a good idea.
Idea Review
Idea Kaylia: Space Avenger (w/ DonaldoC1997 and Coolot1)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Cartoon Network: Invasion of the Thing
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Polter-Girl
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Flytrap: Savior of All
Good Review Coolot: Once a Samurai Jack clone, now a meme starter, not bad.

Paula712: This idea is best.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Miserable Adventures of Riley
Good Review DonaldoC1997: An interesting take on the emo/goth girl stereotype while mixing supernatural as well. Reminds me of Invader Zim and The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy at the same time (well, the protagonist has the same VA as Mandy), but somehow different at the same time.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Holiday Forces
Good Review Coolot1: Power Rangers meets Holidays
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea WB Kids: Idiots to the Rescue!
Good Review Bobbybooboobear: Idiots becoming a superhero team would be funny... Though, it would be better if Dee Dee is in it.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Howler
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Godzilla: Life on Monster Island
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Arachnid Friends
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Dinosaur Crew
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Cosmic Adventures of Stella
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Sajoedri, USA
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Robby Rottweiler
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea I Love Luke
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Fluke
Good Review
Bad Review

Iago PUC

Idea Review
Idea Avengers: Forces from the Infinity
Good Review

Coolot1: Despite being lazy to read it, it is interesting.

35Baragon: This movie is better than the live-action version.

Bobbybooboobear: A nice animated direct-to-TV movie Marvel fans would watch whenever they're bored.

Ricky2005: What an excellent retelling you got there.

Bad Review
Idea Avengers: Forces from the Infinity/Transcript
Good Review 35Baragon: This is a great transcript.

Paula712: This is the best transcript ever.

Bad Review
Idea James Cameron's Sonic
Good Review Coolot1: A great take
Bad Review
Idea Justice League/Teen Titans Chronicles: Dark Kingdom
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Justice League/Teen Titans: Secret Legends
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Comic Con Incorporated
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Ultimate Marvel: Earth-2
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea The Amazing Avengers
Good Review Coolot1: This is an excellent alternate universe, please do a DC version.

Iago PUC: Thank you. And sure. I will see what can be done for it.

Bad Review
Idea Marvel/DC Heroes Unite!
Good Review 35Baragon: Great idea.
Bad Review

Knottyorchid12

Idea Review
Idea 80's Unleashed (film)
Good Review Coolot1: 80's Unleashed is a fun joyride full of twists, laughs and dramatic moments too. The cast is great also. Wazzupguys: 80's Unleashed is a unique idea with peefect casting and over the top plot that would instantly hook you. Can't wait for 90's Unleashed.
Bad Review

Aldrine25

Idea Review
Idea The Powerpuff Babies
Good Review 35Baragon: I've always miss the original The Powerpuff Girls.
Bad Review Coolot1: No offense, but do we need this?

Iago PUC: Never really was a fan of PPG. Besides... it was always meant for a female audience. So all I say is no.

DonaldoC1997: As much I like the PPG (mainly the classic one), is this really needed? I'd undestand if it was a spin-off featuring them a bit older.

SpyroFanandCollinTSB: I have to agree with Don and Coolot... Really? Definitely unneeded.

KKDisney: I don't get it either.

Ricky2005: (facepalm)

GreenGrassCreeper34: If I could describe this with only one word, it would be... trash.

Bobbybooboobear: Nope.avi

TobySilva77: I'm sorry, but do we really need this?

Idea Review
Idea Little Einsteins: Winnie the Pooh and the Honeybees
Good Review Idon'tcareforfilm4: This Will Take Me Back To My Childhood
Bad Review

Coolot1: As I said with The Powerpuff Babies, is this needed?

SpyroFanandCollinTSB: What the heck?! I do admit I liked Winnie the Pooh as my childhood, but that... is the most stupidest idea I've ever seen. What's next, Baby Looney Tunes: How to Train Your Dragon and The Donkey?

DonaldoC1997: I understand they're both Disney, but... no, just no.

GreenGrassCreeper34: Uh... nope!

Bobbybooboobear: Oh, heck no! This reminds me of that Pooh's Adventures stuff.

Ricky2005: This is awful, what's next? The Muppet Babies meet Godzilla?

Firestrikerboss: Sorry, this is honestly a bad idea!

Idea Review
Idea Tom and Jerry Meet Garfield
Good Review Idon'tcareforfilm4: This Is Going To Be The Best Idea Ever.
Bad Review

Coolot1: Why do you make idiotic ideas?

DonaldoC1997: Uhh... no.

GreenGrassCreeper34: Sorry, that idea sounds too nonsensical.

SpyroFanandCollinTSB: Even though Garfield is good and I love Tom and Jerry, No thank you, I pass on that one.

Jadhostgamer072: Garfield Cat and Tom and Jerry? Uh no thanks, sounds like a weird crossover...

Ricky2005: PLEASE STOP IT I DON'T WANT ANY MORE LAUGHABLY BAD FACIAL EXPRESSIONS PLEASE

Idea Review
Idea The Mysterious Mansion of Jasper
Good Review

Idon'tcareforfilm4: It's So Spooky And Fun

SpyroFanandCollinTSB: For a user that made unnecessary ideas, this is actually a good idea.

Firestriker: Great idea!

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Mickey Mouse's Tales
Good Review Idon'tcareforfilm4: That Was A Good Anime
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Terry (Disney-Pixar film)
Good Review Idon'tcareforfilm4: Nice Concept For A Movie
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Zoey McMullen
Good Review Idon'tcareforfilm4: Good Grief That Looks Fun

SmashupMashups: This is something I'd wanna see. And watching a show about the only human character in a populated animal city, what's wrong with that? SpyroFanandCollinTSB: An another good idea from a user who makes bad ideas. Craig might do good with this one.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Looney Puffs
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Cal and Mary
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Extended ending to Buttercrush
Good Review
Bad Review Idon'tcareforfilm4: I Hate The 1998 Original, I Love The 2016 Reboot.
Idea The Fast and the Monstrous (Fanon PPG episode)
Good Review
Bad Review

Bobbybooboobear

Idea Review
Idea Gatopardos the Cheetah
Good Review SpyroFanandCollinTSB: A good way to make anthromorphic animals more heroic and more funny. After all, it is made by Bryan Andrews. If you love Velocity: The Dark Human Slayer, then you may love this show.

Ricky2005: Wow.

GreenGrassCreeper34: A great show with a mixture of action and comedy.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Mobs
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Cartoon Network: United at Last
Good Review GreenGrassCreeper34: Awesome!
Bad Review

GazzaB9

Idea Review
Idea Marvel NEW
Good Review

Coolot1: This is (censored) awesome.

SpyroFanandCollinTSB: Despite the fact I am no longer involved in this, this is actually a brilliant way to reboot some of beloved Marvel comics and give them a new twist.

Jacky 50A: Cool and Spyro are both members, so why not me? By far the only community project that succeds in my point of view. Correct me if I'm wrong, folks. Still, it's a blast working on this thing.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Wander of Wonder
Good Review
Bad Review

KKDisney

Idea Review
Idea The Doggies
Good Review SpyroFanandCollinTSB: Actually a pretty good sitcom idea for a kids' network. It's like a combination of 2 Stupid Dogs and a kid-friendly version of Family Guy.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea What if Walt Disney was the producer of Looney Tunes
Good Review SpyroFanandCollinTSB: That's a good theory twist idea. It's like either Disney owning Looney Tunes or WB owning Mickey Mouse.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Loud House (2002 TV Series) (w/SuperCartoonBrony2000)
Good Review
Bad Review

Coolot1: We don’t need this trash.

DonaldoC1997: I don't understand why this exists.

StephanTheAnimator: If this was even made, I have no doubt that The Loud House would end up like Ren and Stimpy.

Ricky2005: Snore.

Paula712: I don't like this idea at all. I don't want The Loud House would end up like Family Guy and South Park.

GreenGrassCreeper34: Turning a kids' show into a Family Guy/South Park-esque series? Sorry, but this is awful!

Idea Review
Idea Reilly Toons (w/ModernClassicCartoonGamer15)
Good Review 763492/763492 is back: This must be a modern answer to Looney Tunes, Mickey Mouse, Tom and Jerry, etc
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Peanuts (1997 adult TV series)
Good Review
Bad Review Coolot1: Peanuts meets South Park? That must be bad.

Paula712: This is the worst idea ever because mixed South Park and Peanuts is not a good idea.

GreenGrassCreeper34: What the heck is this!? That's all I gotta say.

Firestrikerboss: Even though I love South Park, it doesn't go together with Peanuts.

Idea Review
Idea Cartoon Animal Town
Good Review
Bad Review Coolot1: (insert my eyes meme here)
Idea Review
Idea Amazing Four (w/Coolot and Donaldo)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Bugs Bunny: Attorney at Law (w/SpyroFanandCollinTSB)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Collin: Attorney at Law (w/SpyroFanandCollinTSB)
Good Review
Bad Review

DonaldoC1997

Idea Review
Idea Madame Psych (w/ Coolot1)
Good Review

Coolot1: I know I helped make this idea, but it rocks.

SpyroFanandCollinTSB: A Face Paint character in Batman? That's actually one of the coolest Batman villain ideas I've ever read in my Wiki career.

KKDisney: I like this character. She is a great DC Comics OC.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Good Ol' Magic (w/ Coolot1)
Good Review GreenGrassCreeper34: Love Warner Bros. and Sabrina the Teenage Witch? You'd definitely love this!
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Mystic Woods (w/ Coolot1 and GazzaB9)
Good Review GreenGrassCreeper34: Sounds like a beautiful WB animated movie franchise. This should exist!
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Mysterious Mysteries of Mystery Manor (w/ Coolot1 and GreenGrassCreeper34)
Good Review GreenGrassCreeper34: What an interesting supernatural show. It's like Cartoon Network's answer to Gravity Falls.
Bad Review

Coolot1

Idea Review
Idea Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends (TV series)
Good Review Iago PUC: Quite a impressive idea. As amazing as the titular characters are. (:
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Sonic: Max Justice (w/ DonaldoC1997 and GazzaB9)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Mark: Time Janitor (w/ DonaldoC1997)
Good Review GreenGrassCreeper34: A fun game for those who love the concept of time-travelling.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Thanos' Home (w/ DonaldoC1997)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Crystal the Face Paint Heroine (w/ DonaldoC1997)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Knights of the Wiki
Good Review CLTwins15: It's good. Not that bad but good.
Bad Review

763492/763492 is back

Idea Review
Idea The Amazing Adventures of Spider-Man – Into the Spider-Verse
Good review
Bad review
Idea Review
Idea Universal Metazoa/Attractions
Good review TheLakesideMonster: Pretty neat. I like the idea of a combination between a Universal Studios theme park and a zoo.
Bad review
Idea Review
Idea What if Cuphead debuted in 1930s?
Good review KKDisney: A great idea.
Bad review TheLakesideMonster: This isn't really a bad review, but more of a neutral review. 1930's wouldn't of been much of a good time for Cuphead to debut. I'm not really much of a Cuphead fan anyways, though I could see some good aspects coming out of this idea.
Idea Review
Idea What if DreamWorks Pictures/DreamWorks Animation was founded in 1934?
Good review KKDisney: A great theory and a cool AU.

Ricky2005: This is a good what-if worth reading for a DreamWorks/old cartoon fan.

TheLakesideMonster: An interesting theory that doesn't make sense in a good way.

TobySilva77: I think it's a great theory and a nice AU.

Bad review
Idea Review
Idea Universal Baton Rouge Resort, Universal Metazoa, Universal Studios Louisiana
Good review
Bad review
Idea Review
Idea What if DreamWorks Pictures/DreamWorks Animation was founded in 1934?/Headin’ South
Good review KKDisney: Cool 1940s film idea.
Bad review
Idea Review
Idea What if DreamWorks Pictures/DreamWorks Animation was founded in 1934?/Elefriend
Good review
Bad review
Idea Review
Idea Hollyworld
Good review
Bad review
Ideas Review
Idea What if Lionsgate was founded in early 20th century?
Good review KKDisney: Cool.
Bad review
Ideas Review
Idea Vocaloid World
Good review
Bad review
Idea Review
Idea Movie Experience Parks & Resorts
Good Review KKDisney: Amazing park resort idea.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Wendyland
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea What if Disney would've first start making animated TV series since the 1950s?
Good Review KKDisney: A great interesting TV AU idea.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea SP//dr (TV series)
Good review
Bad review
Idea Review
Idea Marvel Dinosaurs
Good review
Bad review

WindowsMyers2018

Idea Review
Idea The Lion King Reborn
Good Review Coolot1: Interesting take

KKDisney: I like it! A great re-release of one of my favorite animated film mixed with the midquel, TV series spin-offs and sequel into the plot. Iago PUC: Quite a interesting movie. SpyroFanandCollinTSB: A good remaster that has most of the cast returning, and a combination of the films, TV series and even a midquel.

Moon Silvight A Remaster of the entire Lion King Trilogy plus two shows into one? Everyone would love it and it would even introduce newer fans to the trilogy.

GreenGrassCreeper34: Looks really well done.

Ricky2005: A breathtaking idea worth watching for a Lion King fan. Nothing else can be said.

SC01real: No offense... but I think this movie is more watchable than the live-action remake in my opinion.

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Lion King Reborn/Transcript
Good Review Moon Silvight: Seems to be a really good script so far, trying to be faithful to the source material with some additions.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Lion King Reborn (2024 film)
Good Review
Bad Review

Omer1698

Idea Review
Idea The Sorcerer Chronicles
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Musa Revolution
Good Review
Bad Review

GrishamAnimationStudios102

Idea Review
Idea Groove Town
Good Review KKDisney: Cool idea. A great period comedy series and a great sitcom.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Psychedelic Heroes
Good Review KKDisney: Great spin-off.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Melvin and Ronnie
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Cuphead: Don't Deal With The Devil (Hanna-Barbera universe)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea What if The Smurfs had continued production?
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Alvin Movie
Good Review
Bad Review

Bige1218

Idea Review
Idea Marvel Heroes: Infinity War
Good Review Iago PUC: Amazing work you did in this one. And thank you for honoring mine with it.

Paula712: I like this idea so much because I'm a fan of Marvel.

Bad Review

Brady Gliwa

Idea Review
Idea The Loud House Movie
Good Review Coolot1: Despite I am not a fan of Chris Pratt is playing Vice and not sure if he can pull it off, it is a great take on the loud house. UPDATE: Since Pratt is now playing villains, this sounds great.
Bad Review PMF11: This idea, is so poorly written and poorly executed that, it's like Eddie Puss meets Ren and Stimpy. An idea for a movie about The Loud House is fine as it is and it seems kind of cool. But why make one so early when the show has just started? Instead of just waiting for the show's success? This is one of those things that, I don't think I'll ever understand at all. So in other words, this one is a real pass for me.

Ricky2005: Even though it's mediocre in my opinion, the plot is just screaming "EDGY!!!", Maybe said plot should work better for a movie based on a Marvel/Netflix show or something like that. DonaldoC1997: This is so messed up it looks everything but a The Loud House film.

FreezingTNT

Idea Review
Idea Finding Marlin
Good Review Dr Aidan Quinn: Looks enjoyable.

Jadhostgamer072: This idea is actually really good!

75.157.16.123: What I thought of Finding Marlin was "Great idea! It should exist!". - The Ultimate Daredevil, a fan of the Finding Nemo duology

199.216.112.1: Cool.

GreenGrassCreeper34: Nice idea you got there! That would be a good sequel for Finding Nemo and Finding Dory :)

JDancer2017: Not bad, not bad.

Dynasti the Radicles Fangirl: Nice idea.

Demonic Mario 2000: Great idea

TheDiamondGamer110: AWSOME IDEA!

HODGESMC: Finally, a good idea for a Finding Nemo sequel.

Ricky2005: Great idea, Recommendable for a fan of the first 2 "Finding Nemo" movies.

FriendlyGirl48: Amazing!

Paula712: I hope Pixar will make this movie.

Bad Review BirdOfBlueFeathers22: I don't want a Marlin movie, I'd rather have nothing.

CNReactionGuy18

Idea Review
Idea The Reds
Good Review
Bad Review

Paula712

Idea Review
Idea The Mysterious Quest
Good

Review

Firestrikerboss: Nice idea!
Bad

Review

Idea Review
Idea The Amazing World of Supermarket
Good

Review

Bad

Review

Idea Review
Idea We Happy Few 2
Good

Review

Bad

Review

Idea Review
Idea Spy Girl
Good

Review

Bad

Review

FriendlyGirl48

Idea Review
Idea Toonality
Good

Review

Paula712: I love this idea, Glendy!
Bad

Review

Idea Review
Idea The Disney Experience
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Who Framed Gyro Gearloose?
Good

Review

Bad

Review

Firestrikerboss

Idea Review
Idea Fire Striker
Good

Review

Bad

Review

Idea Review
Idea Jason the Demon
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Crazy World of Aaron
Good Review
Bad Review

TheLakesideMonster

Idea Review
Idea Knights of RedCliff: The Series
Good Review TheLakesideMonster: My most popular original show on the wiki. I really put a lot of thought into this idea. Actual RedCliff members on Roblox sometimes tease me for the creation of this idea though, lol.

GreenGrassCreeper34: Excellent spin-off!

Paula712: Amazing!

Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Primal Prey II (Primal Prey: Extinction)
Good Review TheLakesideMonster: My very first original idea on Idea Wiki. I put my heart and soul into this idea, even though I may have butchered it with detail. I think a sequel to a very underrated game with a lot of extra spice would be really good, but it would never happen.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Red Dead Redemption 2: Undead Nightmare 2
Good Review TheLakesideMonster: Not sure if a lot of people on Idea Wiki are fans/players of the Red Dead game series, but Undead Nightmare from the original Red Dead Redemption really blew me away with how fantastically creepy and fun it was. I think Rockstar should really consider making a non-canon Undead Nightmare prequel for Red Dead Redemption 2.

GreenGrassCreeper34: A mixture of western and supernatural is quite interesting.

Bad Review

Bloo J 2.0 W10 Computer Version

Idea Review
Idea BlooJ's Foster's Sliver Screen for Imaginary Movies (2003 film)
Good Review
Bad Review

GreenGrassCreeper34: ...It's awful.

TheLakesideMonster: Please stop ruining Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends.

TobySilva77: I'm sorry, but this is not a good idea.

Idea Review
Idea BlooJ's Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends: Reimagined!
Good Review
Bad Review GreenGrassCreeper34: (facepalms, then tears my entire face off)

Paula712: Seriously?

DonaldoC1997: That was one of the most stupid ideas I ever read.

TheLakesideMonster: Why did you just cram together a lot of genres and actors just to butcher a beloved classic CN show?

TobySilva77: Nope.avi

TobySilva77

Idea Review
Idea South High (franchise)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea IONYouth
Good Review DevlinWho: One word: Yes.
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Super Mario Maker 3
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Real Adventures of Gilligan
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Jetix on Freeform
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea A Cry in the Wild (2020 remake)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Holes (TV series) (w/ KKDisney)
Good Review
Bad Review Coolot1: Where's My flamethrower? Cause this idea needs to burn. Just burn.
Idea Review
Idea Stickin' Around Rewritten
Good Review
Bad Review Coolot1: National obsession day
Idea Review
Idea Shake! (revival)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea What if Nelvana Limited was founded in 1942?
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea Fox Kids (revival)
Good Review
Bad Review
Idea Review
Idea The Ballad of Samurai Asahi
Good Review
Bad Review


Trivia

Start a Discussion Discussions about Idea Wiki Review

  • Reviews

    7 messages
    • ReianaSmiley wrote: What about my SMP Air Date Poll! Aren't you going to vote on it# Calm down. I just did.
    • I think that the rules should be editted so the admins and other reviewers should say why bad ideas are bad, without just saying "this i...
  • Reviews on my ideas

    3 messages
    • Why don't you do it?
    • Real rule 7
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.