Star and Mewni Creek/Tropes/YMMV


 * And You Thought It Would Fail/Author's Saving Throw: As everybody thought that the revival wasn't about to be a success, it suddenly showed them wrong when the re-hiring of Skyler Page brought the show back on top, reprising the title character, as well as writing episodes again, in which repaired the show's fanbase.
 * Base-Breaking Character: Amy starts receiving this after her re-appearance in the crossover episode. As having a different voice actress and suddenly acting like a teenager. Although it's justified, as Amy is going through adolescence. In later seasons, her base is restored as she becomes more kind as before in her debut episode, but still retaining a little of her teenage genes.
 * Cult Classic: Averted. Due to the return of Skyler Page, its label for being a cult-classic was removed and is now labeled as "overrated", along with shows such as Adventure Time, Regular Show, and Steven Universe as well.
 * Growing the Beard: The show reaches this after its fifth season's episodes "The Great Clarence Caper", "Halloween in Aberdale", "Friends, Family & Fueds", "Mel & Marv", and "Mr. Randell".
 * Season 6's Star Wars episodes were mostly helpful in putting the show up on top.
 * However, most of the revival's episodes featuring guest stars could be the case...
 * It's Popular, Now It Sucks!: Despite the show's regain in popularity, some old fans of the show think it should have stayed cancelled.
 * Seasonal Rot: The fourth season was often criticized for simply having less focus on the original characters of the show and mostly focused on the six main characters. Fortunately, the following seasons were able to rectify it, with having a few episodes focused on each character, including ones that were never shown on-screen before.
 * They Changed It, Now It Sucks!: Some fans of the show were disappointed with the changes on the show, such as Clarence and Jeff transferring to West Aberdale, or Mary losing weight, switching voice actors, and let's not forget Amy's new personality and return to the series.
 * They Wasted a Perfectly Good Character: Breehn's new baby brother Gene only appeared three times in the show, in which some fans were left disappointed that they didn't get to see more of the character.
 * Win Back the Crowd: As far as the show's original run went, the revival's improvement and better written episodes make it far better than the original airing.